The Counter-Example: Why Software Pay Gaps Are Mostly Just Cost of Living
Every other occupation in this series shows a pay gap larger than the local cost of living explains. Software developers show one that is smaller — 0.95×, below one. That is the interesting part.
The decomposition
The headline gap is 1.45×. Part of that is simply that San Francisco pays every occupation 1.53× what St. Louis pays. Dividing one by the other leaves 0.95× that the local market does not explain.
| Figure | San Francisco | St. Louis | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Software Developers median | $174,910 | $120,490 | 1.45× |
| Median across all occupations | $73,960 | $48,290 | 1.53× |
| Residual | — | — | 0.95× |
Why the gap is this wide
Software developers behave differently from every other occupation here, and the difference is the point.
The occupation premium between San Francisco and St. Louis is 1.45x. The general metro premium between those same two metros is 1.53x. The residual is 0.95x — below one.
In other words, software pay in San Francisco relative to what that metro pays for everything else is slightly lower than in St. Louis. The entire headline gap is the metro's general wage level, not an occupation-specific premium. And that is despite an extraordinary cluster: the location quotient in San Francisco is 2.98, with 76,900 people employed in the occupation, against 0.65 and 9,360 in St. Louis.
The most defensible reading is that software pay is set in a genuinely national market. Remote work, national compensation bands at large employers, and equity packages benchmarked to a national scale mean broadly the same band is applied in both metros — and it looks larger in San Francisco only because everything else there is larger too.
The caveat here is large enough to change the conclusion, so it needs stating plainly. OEWS measures wages and excludes equity and bonus. For software that is not a rounding error: equity is a substantial share of compensation, and it is concentrated in exactly the metros at the top of this table. Read the 0.95x residual as "wages only". The total-compensation gap between San Francisco and St. Louis for software developers is wider than this analysis shows — but it is wider within the occupation, which is a different claim from the one the rest of this series makes.
What this means
Software pay is set in a national market, so the metro premium dominates. The caveat is large: these figures exclude equity, which is concentrated in exactly the metros at the top of the table.
Figures: BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2024. Nominal wages, no cost-of-living adjustment. Employers only, so self-employed and contract workers are excluded. Wages only — no bonus, equity or benefits, which matters enough to change the conclusion in two of these analyses.
The method is explained in How to Tell Whether a Pay Gap Is Really About the Job. Full detail in the methodology.